_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
CH-CH-CH-CHANGES
Here is the completely true, totally unembellished, occasionally frustrating, but often entertaining story of how a book I wrote that was once called CHASERS became the book currently known as WITH OR WITHOUT YOU. To really appreciate the process, it’s best to look at the timeline:
2005
After having dinner with a friend who was going to nursing school to treat patients with HIV and AIDS, I get the first inklings of the idea for a book. I do a bit of research and, as I’ve just started an MFA program and know I’ll need to write a book for my thesis, I start taking many notes on where the story might go, who the characters are.
2006
“The Project” is about 1/3 of the way done and it needs a name. Something better than “The Project.” I spend nights thinking about it. I spend days thinking about it. I create a small altar and sacrifice marshmallow Peeps in the hopes that a good idea will come to me. I finally settle on calling it CHASERS, after a group of the same name that is central to the story. I’m not wild about it but it works. I am thoroughly convinced that a new and better title will come to me by the time I have to turn the finished book in as my thesis.
2007
I am mind-bogglingly wrong. No better title comes. First draft is finished. Revisions begin. Somewhere in this book there’s a wonderful title just waiting to get out.
The wonderful title has decided it does not want to come out. It wants to keep hiding. The wonderful title turns out to be a big tease. I start to hate the wonderful title and I don’t even know what it is. Trying to explain to my writing group why I hate an unknown title only earns me sideways glances and whispers behind my back. I turn CHASERS (then a whopping 96,000 words) in as my thesis. My thesis committee says very nice things. Nowhere in the nice things can I find a better title.
2009
I finish rewrites so the book is much more svelte and send it out to agents as CHASERS. A wonderful agent named Robert Guinsler from Sterling Lord Literistic offers to represent me. He has no better idea what to call it so he shops it around as CHASERS.
2009—Later
Offers come in for the book. It’s a tough decision but we go with Simon Pulse. I’m convinced they will want to change the title as “chasers” would be confused with a popular alcoholic beverage (and the book is not about alcoholic beverages).
2010
Simon Pulse seems fine with CHASERS as the title.
2010—Later
Nope, time to change the title. The title we’re going for is supposed to play up the drama angle (there is a lot of drama in the book). A dramatic title will attract a certain audience. My editor and I start brainstorming titles. All of the following are discussed and subsequently rejected:
LIFE AT THE SPEED OF STUPID
MARKED
NOWHERE FAST
CONTACT
2010—Later still
Nope. CHASERS really does seem like the best title. It’s a go!
2011
“It’s a go” gets redefined as “It’s not a go!” After further marketing analysis, a better strategy to reach the biggest possible audience is to play up the romantic aspects of the book more so than the drama. I am okay with this. To me, the story is really about the rise of one relationship in the shadow of one that’s falling apartment. The relationships are important so a title that reflects that will work best.
But, remember, this is the guy who couldn’t think beyond CHASERS as the title. The elusive wonderful title has been thumbing its nose at me for almost six years now. I have no choice. I must at last think….out of the box. I took a good look at the book, and said “What’s really going on?” I thought about the main character, Evan, who’s facing a choice: he can move to California to be with his boyfriend or he can stay at home in Madison and keep an eye on his best friend, Davis, who’s gotten involved with a dangerous group of guys. He suddenly realizes that he faces a future without one of the two most important people in his life. He’s going to have to live with or without one of them. That’s more or less where the title sprang from. It has resonance throughout the book. It’s a threat (“I’m doing this with or without you”). And it’s also a question (“What will I do if I stay with you? What will I do if I choose to go on without you?”).
So…. I suggest WITH OR WITHOUT YOU to Simon Pulse. They go bananas for it and a title is born.
2011—Later
Title still WITH OR WITHOUT YOU? Yep? OK, just checking.
And that is the story of how I got my title. Thanks, Brent, for letting me ramble on. Now, before I go, if you’ll indulge me in a quick plug: check out my blog for the details on a couple contests I’m having. Writers could win a full manuscript critique by a real live editor (c’est moi) and readers could win a slew of signed, first edition books. Click the link below to learn more!
[BRENT SPEAKING: Brian's super-huge contest can be found here: http://bit.ly/lCC6kC.]
Brian Farrey’s debut YA novel, WITH OR WITHOUT YOU, will be published May 24 by Simon Pulse. He tweets @BrianFarrey and he blogs at www.brianfarreybooks.com/wordpress.








